Honest review of Coming Home

by Edith Wharton (Author)

Edith Wharton's Coming Home offers a poignant exploration of love, sacrifice, and the enduring wounds of war. Set against the brutal backdrop of World War I, the novel follows John Campton's return to a France ravaged by conflict. His journey is one of reconnection, not only with his estranged mother but also with the devastating realities of a nation shattered. Wharton masterfully weaves a tale of resilience and heartbreak, delving into themes of family, loyalty, and the profound emotional scars left by war. Through keen insight and graceful prose, Coming Home provides both an intimate character study and a vivid portrayal of wartime Europe, leaving the reader to contemplate the lasting personal and collective costs of conflict. This lesser-known work stands as a testament to Wharton's enduring literary genius.

Coming Home
3.6 / 19 ratings

Review Coming Home

Oh, Coming Home… what a bittersweet experience. Edith Wharton's mastery of language shines through in this poignant novella, a smaller-scale work than some of her other novels, but no less impactful. It’s almost like a beautifully crafted short story, incredibly concise yet brimming with emotion. The story itself, set against the backdrop of World War I, focuses not on the trenches, but on the lingering effects of war on the home front – a fascinating and often overlooked aspect of the conflict. We see the shattered landscape reflected in the lives of the characters, particularly John Campton's return to a France irrevocably changed, and the fractured relationship he must repair with his mother.

Wharton’s signature grace is evident in her prose; she paints such vivid pictures of the emotional turmoil and the subtle shifts in relationships. The descriptions of the setting, both physical and emotional, are exquisite. You feel the weight of the war's aftermath, the unspoken grief and the struggle to rebuild lives shattered by loss and separation. It’s a story that lingers in your mind long after you finish reading, prompting reflection on the enduring cost of conflict, both on a personal and collective level. It's a testament to the lasting power of love, the sacrifices we make for those we cherish, and the heartbreaking resilience of the human spirit.

Now, I must confess, my experience wasn't entirely unmarred. I was reading a particular edition, and sadly, the typesetting was truly abysmal. The lack of proper paragraph breaks and the absence of any indentation made it considerably harder to enjoy the actual content. It's a frustrating distraction, particularly when you're trying to absorb the nuances of Wharton's writing. It felt like reading a poorly formatted manuscript rather than a finished product, and it unfortunately detracted from the overall reading experience. It’s a shame because the story itself deserves a better presentation; it's a gem that deserves to be appreciated without such hindrances.

Despite the formatting issues of the edition I encountered, the core of Wharton's story remains powerful and moving. It's a classic example of her ability to explore the complexities of human relationships under extraordinary circumstances. The sadness inherent in these wartime tales is palpable, but it's a sadness that feels honest and deeply affecting, interwoven with moments of hope and quiet strength. It's one of those stories that stays with you, prompting reflection on the fragility of life and the enduring power of human connection, even amidst the devastation of war. If you're a fan of historical fiction or simply appreciate beautifully written prose, I would recommend seeking out a well-typeset edition of Coming Home—you won’t be disappointed by the story itself.

Information

  • Dimensions: 6 x 0.15 x 9 inches
  • Language: English
  • Print length: 63
  • Publication date: 2025

Preview Book

Coming HomeComing HomeComing HomeComing HomeComing Home